Which Is the Best Pencil Eyeliner?

1. Overdoing It on the Bottom Lid. Heavily Lining Your Lower Lid — Especially with a Very Dark Color — Can Make Your Eyes Look Smaller, Says Mary Clarke, a Product Analyst in the Good Housekeeping Research Institute Beauty Lab. Plus, You're More Likely to End up with Under-Eye Smudges.

Should You Put Eyeliner on Your Bottom Lid?

1. Overdoing It on the Bottom Lid. Heavily Lining Your Lower Lid — Especially with a Very Dark Color — Can Make Your Eyes Look Smaller, Says Mary Clarke, a Product Analyst in the Good Housekeeping Research Institute Beauty Lab. Plus, You're More Likely to End up with Under-Eye Smudges.

Testing the Best Drugstore Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils (Waterline, Smoky Eye, Smudge-Proof)

You Can Also Opt to Apply It onto the Lid and Not the Waterline to Avoid the Eyeliner Getting into Your Eye. Does Waterproof Eyeliner Smudge? Waterproof Eyeliner Should Not Smudge, Thanks to It's Formula.

What Is the Best Selling Eyeliner?

You Can Also Opt to Apply It onto the Lid and Not the Waterline to Avoid the Eyeliner Getting into Your Eye. Does Waterproof Eyeliner Smudge? Waterproof Eyeliner Should Not Smudge, Thanks to It's Formula.

How Do You Keep Mascara from Smudging Under Your Eyes?

You Can Also Opt to Apply It onto the Lid and Not the Waterline to Avoid the Eyeliner Getting into Your Eye. Does Waterproof Eyeliner Smudge? Waterproof Eyeliner Should Not Smudge, Thanks to It's Formula.

Does Waterproof Eyeliner Smudge?

You Can Also Opt to Apply It onto the Lid and Not the Waterline to Avoid the Eyeliner Getting into Your Eye. Does Waterproof Eyeliner Smudge? Waterproof Eyeliner Should Not Smudge, Thanks to It's Formula.

How Do You Make Homemade Smudge Proof Eyeliner?

In Pretty Much All Cases, Liquid Eyeliner Is Darker and More Richly Pigmented Than Pencil. Because of This, a Stroke of Eyeliner Delivers Bold, Look-at-Me Lines. Perfect for Dramatic Looks. Team Liquid with a Pencil Eyeliner to Build Intensity for a Smokey Eye.

What Type of Eyeliner Lasts Longest?

In Pretty Much All Cases, Liquid Eyeliner Is Darker and More Richly Pigmented Than Pencil. Because of This, a Stroke of Eyeliner Delivers Bold, Look-at-Me Lines. Perfect for Dramatic Looks. Team Liquid with a Pencil Eyeliner to Build Intensity for a Smokey Eye.

What Kind of Eyeliner Should Beginners Use?

In Pretty Much All Cases, Liquid Eyeliner Is Darker and More Richly Pigmented Than Pencil. Because of This, a Stroke of Eyeliner Delivers Bold, Look-at-Me Lines. Perfect for Dramatic Looks. Team Liquid with a Pencil Eyeliner to Build Intensity for a Smokey Eye.

Is an Eye Pencil the Same as Eyeliner?

In Pretty Much All Cases, Liquid Eyeliner Is Darker and More Richly Pigmented Than Pencil. Because of This, a Stroke of Eyeliner Delivers Bold, Look-at-Me Lines. Perfect for Dramatic Looks. Team Liquid with a Pencil Eyeliner to Build Intensity for a Smokey Eye.

Is It Bad to Put Eyeliner on Your Waterline?

First Thing's First, You May Be Wondering If Eyeliner Is Safe for Your Waterline. the Eyes Are a Sensitive Area, So It Makes Sense That Applying Eyeliner So Close to Your Eyes Could Cause Irritation. .. . the Point Is: Yes, Eyeliner Is Safe for Your Waterline—If You're Using the Right Product.

What Kind of Eyeliner Is Best for Waterline?

"The Moisture and Oils from the Eye Cream Mixes with the Heat and Oils from the Skin. This Heat Rises up Toward the Mascara and Affects the Formula of the Mascara, Which Breaks Down the Ingredients to Form Those Dreaded Mascara Bleeds and Smudges."

Why Does My Mascara Keep Smudging Under My Eyes?

"The Moisture and Oils from the Eye Cream Mixes with the Heat and Oils from the Skin. This Heat Rises up Toward the Mascara and Affects the Formula of the Mascara, Which Breaks Down the Ingredients to Form Those Dreaded Mascara Bleeds and Smudges."

Why Does My Mascara Always Run Under My Eyes?

It's the Oil. After All, Oil Is an Excellent Makeup Remover—and That Includes the Oil Your Face Produces. .. . Just Like Oils on Your Face Break Down Foundation, So Will They Break Down Your Mascara.

What Mascara Does Not Smudge?

Gel Eyeliner Has a Texture Somewhere Between an Eye Pencil and a Liquid Eyeliner. the Consistency Is Thicker Than Liquid Liner, and It's Creamy Like an Eye Pencil. .. . for a Look That Stays in Place and Is Less Likely to Smudge Once Its Set Than the Average Eye Pencil, Gel Eyeliner Is a Great Option.

Is Gel Eyeliner Better Than Pencil?

Gel Eyeliner Has a Texture Somewhere Between an Eye Pencil and a Liquid Eyeliner. the Consistency Is Thicker Than Liquid Liner, and It's Creamy Like an Eye Pencil. .. . for a Look That Stays in Place and Is Less Likely to Smudge Once Its Set Than the Average Eye Pencil, Gel Eyeliner Is a Great Option.

Which Is Better Eyeliner Pencil or Liquid?

In Pretty Much All Cases, Liquid Eyeliner Is Darker and More Richly Pigmented Than Pencil. Because of This, a Stroke of Eyeliner Delivers Bold, Look-at-Me Lines. Perfect for Dramatic Looks. Team Liquid with a Pencil Eyeliner to Build Intensity for a Smokey Eye.

Which Eyeliner Pencil Doesn't Smudge?

By Robert Thorne

• Oct 8, 2026 • 6 min read

Direct Answer • Key Takeaway

One of the Main Reasons Your Eyeliner Smudges Is Because of Oil—Whether It's Natural Oil from Your Skin or from Your Moisturizer. Start Your Makeup Routine with a Clean Face, and If You Want to Apply Moisturizer Around Your Eyes, Use a Product That Is Lightweight to Reduce the Risk of Your Eyeliner Smearing Later On.

Robert Thorne

Automotive & Future Transportation Editor

Robert Thorne covers electric vehicle innovations, autonomous driving systems, global mobility trends, and automotive engineering developments.

Tags: which eyeliner pencil doesnt smudge